The Teachers Service Commission (TSC) has rejected a document circulating on social media that purported to show newly appointed Secretary and Chief Executive Officer Cheptumo Ayabei finishing fourth in recruitment interviews with a score of 57 percent.
In a statement issued Tuesday, the Commission described the document as fraudulent and warned the public against relying on its contents, which had fueled widespread online debate over allegations of tribal favoritism in the appointment.
“The Teachers Service Commission wishes to warn the general public against a fraudulent document currently circulating on social media regarding the ‘Submission of Interview Results for the Position of Secretary/Chief Executive Officer’,” the Commission stated. “We wish to clarify that the document in question is not only FAKE but misleading”.
The disputed letter, dated November 16, 2026, and purportedly signed by TSC Chairperson Dr. Jamleck Muturi John, was addressed to Chief of Staff and Head of Public Service Felix Koskei. It claimed that Robert Odette from Migori County topped the interviews with 96 percent, followed by Lawrence Ngai Kaburu with 84 percent, Dr. Evaleen Jesang Mitei with 79 percent, Ayabei with 57 percent, and Farah Abdi Saman with 43 percent.
The document’s recommendation section allegedly stated that Odette had demonstrated the professional qualifications and leadership capacity required for the position, prompting questions online about why Ayabei was ultimately appointed instead.
The purported results gained traction after an X user, @muchogokariuki, shared the document alongside allegations that public appointments were being driven by ethnic connections rather than merit.
“The appointment of the TSC CEO has exposed the truth without disguise: Kenya does not belong to all of us. It belongs to those who occupy State House,” the user wrote, according to The Kenya Times.
The Commission did not directly address the tribal favoritism allegations but urged the public to verify information through its official channels, including its website (tsc.go.ke), Facebook page (TSC KENYA), and X handle (@TSC_KE).

The controversy followed TSC’s announcement on Monday, November 16, 2026, that Ayabei, who previously served as the Commission’s Director of Finance, would become its new Secretary and CEO. He was selected from five shortlisted candidates out of 124 applicants who applied after the position was re-advertised.
Ayabei’s appointment filled the vacancy left by former CEO Nancy Macharia, who retired in June 2025 after a decade at the helm. Dr. Evaleen Jesang Mitei had been serving as acting CEO in the interim.
Ayabei joined TSC in 1999 as a Finance Officer and rose to become Director of Finance in 2009. He holds a Bachelor of Education degree from Kenyatta University, a Master’s degree in Finance and Banking from the University of Stirling in the United Kingdom, and is a Certified Public Accountant.
He is also the first person with a disability to lead the Commission.
The recruitment exercise had a turbulent history after the High Court in Kiambu nullified an earlier process on September 17, 2026. A two-judge bench found that the initial advertisement gave applicants only 13 days to apply instead of the required 14 and failed to disclose the proposed remuneration for the position. The court ordered the process to be restarted.
TSC re-advertised the position on September 29, 2026, with applications closing on October 30. Interviews were held on November 16, the same day Ayabei’s appointment was announced.
The Commission has maintained that the recruitment was conducted in accordance with the Constitution and the Teachers Service Commission Act, 2012. However, it has not released an official breakdown of the interview scores following the controversy.












